Step 1
What is a tuning?
A note's pitch is how fast it vibrates, counted in hertz (Hz), vibrations a second. With Sa on C sharp, Sa vibrates 138.59 times a second. A tuning sets the exact pitch of every other note.
Double the frequency, and you get the same note one octave higher: upper Sa, at 277.18 Hz. The two blend so well that every tuning keeps the octave at exactly double. A tuning decides where the eleven notes between Sa and upper Sa go.
This guide compares two tunings:
- Standard tuning
- Equal temperament, which matches most keyboards.
- Harmonic tuning
- Just intonation, which uses simple frequency ratios to blend each note with Sa.
Standard and Harmonic are the names Ragafied's tools use. Equal temperament and just intonation are the technical names, which musicians and textbooks use.
Step 2
Standard tuning: divide the octave into twelve equal steps
The most common answer divides the octave into twelve equal steps, called semitones. That gives the twelve notes. This is Standard tuning, and its technical name is equal temperament.
Equal here means equal ratios, not equal hertz. Each step multiplies the frequency by the same number, the twelfth root of 2, which is about 1.0595. Twelve steps multiply it by exactly 2, one octave. The ear hears equal ratios as equal distances, so every step sounds the same size. On a logarithmic scale, which counts doublings, the twelve notes are evenly spaced.
Musicians measure small pitch differences in cents. A semitone has 100 cents, so an octave has 1,200.
Because every step is the same size, music sounds the same in every key, and you can move Sa without retuning. Pianos, keyboards, fretted guitars, and most harmoniums use Standard tuning.
Step 3
Harmonic tuning: another way to place the notes
There is another way to place the notes. Harmonic tuning places each note at a simple ratio of whole numbers to Sa. Pa vibrates 3 times for every 2 vibrations of Sa, a ratio of 3:2. Ga vibrates 5 times for every 4, a ratio of 5:4.
On a string, a ratio is a length. Pa sounds from 2/3 of Sa's string, and Ga from 4/5. The picture shows each note's string as a share of Sa's, with a dot where it ends, like a fret. The ticks on the bottom line mark where Standard tuning puts its frets.
The technical name for Harmonic tuning is just intonation. The vocal pitch graph can draw its note lines in either tuning.
Tap a note to pluck its string.
- Sa 1:1 Sa, 1:1, sounds from 1/1 of Sa's string.
- Komal Re 16:15 Komal Re, 16:15, sounds from 15/16 of Sa's string.
- Re 9:8 Re, 9:8, sounds from 8/9 of Sa's string.
- Komal Ga 6:5 Komal Ga, 6:5, sounds from 5/6 of Sa's string.
- Ga 5:4 Ga, 5:4, sounds from 4/5 of Sa's string.
- Ma 4:3 Ma, 4:3, sounds from 3/4 of Sa's string.
- Teevra Ma 45:32 Teevra Ma, 45:32, sounds from 32/45 of Sa's string.
- Pa 3:2 Pa, 3:2, sounds from 2/3 of Sa's string.
- Komal Dha 8:5 Komal Dha, 8:5, sounds from 5/8 of Sa's string.
- Dha 5:3 Dha, 5:3, sounds from 3/5 of Sa's string.
- Komal Ni 9:5 Komal Ni, 9:5, sounds from 5/9 of Sa's string.
- Ni 15:8 Ni, 15:8, sounds from 8/15 of Sa's string.
- Upper Sa 2:1 Upper Sa, 2:1, sounds from 1/2 of Sa's string.
Step 4
Hear both tunings in a sung chord
Each recording is one voice singing Sa, Ga, and Pa one at a time, layered into a major chord. Both play at the same loudness. Only the tuning changes. Headphones make the difference easier to hear.
Or loop the chord, and switch tunings while it plays
In Standard tuning, Ga and Pa sit slightly off simple ratios to Sa, so the chord beats: its loudness flutters several times a second. In Harmonic tuning the fast beats stop, and the chord sounds smoother.
Step 5
See where the two tunings differ
Pa and Ma differ by only 2 cents. In Harmonic tuning, Ga, Dha, and Ni sit 12 to 16 cents lower than in Standard tuning, and the komal notes sit 12 to 18 cents higher. Re sits 4 cents higher, and teevra Ma 10 cents lower.
Harmonic tuning Standard tuning
Hear a note with Sa in each tuning
| Note | Ratio to Sa | Harmonic tuning | Standard tuning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sa | 1:1 | 0.0 | 0 |
| Komal Re | 16:15 | 111.7 | 100 |
| Re | 9:8 | 203.9 | 200 |
| Komal Ga | 6:5 | 315.6 | 300 |
| Ga | 5:4 | 386.3 | 400 |
| Ma | 4:3 | 498.0 | 500 |
| Teevra Ma | 45:32 | 590.2 | 600 |
| Pa | 3:2 | 702.0 | 700 |
| Komal Dha | 8:5 | 813.7 | 800 |
| Dha | 5:3 | 884.4 | 900 |
| Komal Ni | 9:5 | 1,017.6 | 1,000 |
| Ni | 15:8 | 1,088.3 | 1,100 |
| Upper Sa | 2:1 | 1,200.0 | 1,200 |
Step 6
Why they sound different: overtones and beats
A sung or played note is not one frequency. It also sounds quieter overtones at 2, 3, 4, 5, and more times its frequency. Their mix gives a voice or an instrument its tone.
When two notes sound together, some of their overtones land close together. Two tones a few hertz apart beat: the sound swells and fades as many times a second as the tones are hertz apart.
With simple ratios, these overtones land on exactly the same frequency, so they don't beat. With Sa on C sharp, 5 × Sa and 4 × Ga are both 692.96 Hz in Harmonic tuning. In Standard tuning they are 5.5 Hz apart, so the chord flutters 5.5 times a second.
| Overtones | Harmonic tuning | Standard tuning |
|---|---|---|
| 3 × Sa and 2 × Pa | Both 415.77 Hz | 0.47 Hz apart: a slow swell about every 2 seconds |
| 5 × Sa and 4 × Ga | Both 692.96 Hz | 5.5 Hz apart: a flutter |
| 6 × Sa and 4 × Pa | Both 831.55 Hz | 0.94 Hz apart: a swell about once a second |
| 6 × Ga and 5 × Pa | Both 1,039.43 Hz | 9.42 Hz apart: a fast flutter |
Beating overtones also explain why some intervals sound harsh. Tones sound roughest when they are close but not quite together, about a quarter of a critical band apart (Plomp and Levelt, 1965).
Step 7
Why pianos use Standard tuning anyway
Pure intervals don't all fit in one octave. Twelve pure fifths (3:2) overshoot seven octaves by about 23.5 cents, a gap called the Pythagorean comma. Build a scale from pure fifths, and the last fifth comes out badly out of tune.
Start on Sa. Each fifth goes up by 3:2. When it passes upper Sa, it drops an octave.
A keyboard has one key per note, so its tuner has to choose. European keyboards used Pythagorean tuning with pure fifths, then meantone tunings with pure major thirds from the 16th to the 18th century, then well temperaments, in which every key is playable and each key sounds a little different. Bach's The Well-Tempered Clavier was probably written for such a tuning, not for equal temperament.
Equal temperament, today's Standard tuning, spreads the comma evenly: each fifth is about 2 cents narrow, and every key sounds the same. Piano makers adopted it in the mid-1800s, Broadwood in England around 1846, and it has been the standard since the 20th century.
Step 8
Why a harmonium and a tanpura disagree
A tanpura plays only Sa and Pa, or Sa and Ma or Ni for some ragas, and never a melody. Its curved bridge, the jawari, with a thread under each string, gives every pluck a dense band of bright overtones. Sa and Pa have no komal or teevra forms, so the tanpura is the fixed reference a singer tunes to.
When your note matches the tanpura, your voice's overtones land on the tanpura's own. Your voice blends into the drone, and the tanpura's sound changes. This is easiest to hear on Pa, Ga, and Ma, and fainter on Re, Dha, and Ni.
A harmonium has fixed reeds, mostly in Standard tuning, and came into Hindustani music in the late 1800s. Its Pa is only 2 cents from the tanpura's, but its Ga is about 14 cents above Ga in Harmonic tuning. Many musicians objected to it, and All India Radio banned the harmonium from 1940 to 1971.
Step 9
How singers actually tune
The Natyashastra, an ancient Indian text on the performing arts, describes 22 shrutis in an octave. It gives no ratios. The ratios in modern shruti tables are later assignments, and scholars disagree about them.
Measurements of real performances show no fixed table. A 2011 study of 233 Carnatic and 133 Hindustani vocal recordings found Carnatic intervals close to just intonation, and Hindustani intervals a mix of just intonation and equal temperament. Singers also place the same note differently, depending on the raga and the singer.
So Harmonic tuning is a better guide than Standard tuning when you sing with a tanpura, and your ear and your teacher remain the final guide.
Your turn
Now check your own singing
The vocal pitch graph draws your voice as a line over the notes, in Standard or Harmonic tuning. Choose Harmonic in Settings, turn on the tanpura, and see where your Ga lands.